Buying Property in a Downturn Australia: Bad Idea?

Brand-new Australian homes in a growth corridor during golden hour

Buying property in a downturn Australia is not automatically a bad idea. For disciplined investors, late 2026 is creating rare buyer leverage: prices are resetting, rental markets remain tight, and Inner Circle Group is using data, not fear, to target quality new-build assets in undersupplied growth corridors.

“Most investors lose money in the five minutes they spend falling in love with a kitchen. We spend weeks on the data before we ever show a client a property,” says Ben Ferrett, Founder & CEO of Inner Circle Group.

Is buying property in a downturn Australia a bad idea?

No — a downturn is only dangerous when you confuse a lower price with a better investment. The opportunity is not to buy anything cheap. The opportunity is to buy the right asset when competition, vendor expectations and panic have all moved in your favour.

That is the market we are seeing now. Domain reported that house prices declined across every Australian capital city in the September 2026 quarter for the first time in 15 years and only the second time on record, with the national market recording a second consecutive quarterly fall.

To rookies, that sounds like a reason to hide. To serious investors, it is a signal to sharpen the pencil. Risk is not lower because the headline price is lower; risk is lower when the purchase price, rental demand, future supply and suburb fundamentals all stack up together.

What changed in the late-2026 property market?

Prices reset and buyers finally regained leverage. Domain said September 2026 selling conditions had shifted in buyers’ favour, with seasonally low auction clearance rates, elevated days on market and increased discounting.

That matters because property is normally an emotional game. When everyone is confident, vendors get greedy, buyers rush, and the best sites disappear quickly. In a downturn, disciplined investors can negotiate harder, compare more stock, and walk away from anything that does not meet the numbers.

The reset was broad but not uniform. Domain recorded combined capital unit prices falling 3.5% in the September 2026 quarter, compared with a steeper 4.7% fall in house prices. Product selection matters. A house, townhouse and apartment can behave very differently in the same suburb.

In ICG target markets, the pullback created real movement. Brisbane house prices fell 5.4% in the September 2026 quarter while annual growth remained positive at 5.3%. Perth house prices fell 7.4% for the quarter while annual growth was still positive at 6.8%. Adelaide house prices fell 3.0% after a 13-quarter run of growth, while annual growth remained positive at 6.4%.

Why is this not simply a demand-collapse story?

Because rental markets are still brutally tight in the places investors should be watching. Purchase prices can fall while tenant demand remains strong, and that gap is where smart investors start doing serious work.

Brisbane rents held at record highs in the September 2026 quarter, with Domain reporting $700 per week for houses, $660 per week for units, a 0.7% vacancy rate and rental listings 3.0% lower than a year earlier.

Adelaide deserves equal attention. Domain reported Adelaide rents at record highs of $650 per week for houses and $550 per week for units, with vacancy falling to 0.4% and rental listings down 22.8% year on year. That is not a sleepy side market; that is a rental market with serious pressure.

Perth was just as tight, with Domain reporting record rents of $750 per week for houses and $700 per week for units, a 0.4% vacancy rate and rental listings down 11.3% year on year. Melbourne was steadier but still firm, with house and unit rents both at record highs of $600 per week and vacancy at 1.4%.

That is the myth-buster. A downturn in prices does not automatically mean demand has disappeared. Sometimes it means buyers are nervous while renters are still competing for scarce homes.

What is still driving housing demand?

Population growth is still adding households, and households need somewhere to live. The ABS reported Australia’s population was 27,921,150 at 31 March 2026, up 392,700 people or 1.4% over the year, with net overseas migration adding 292,100 people.

The growth is not evenly spread, which is exactly why national headlines are lazy. In the year to March 2026, the ABS recorded Western Australia as Australia’s fastest-growing state at 2.1%, while Victoria and Queensland both grew 1.6%.

This is why ICG does not buy on headlines. We focus on Brisbane and South East Queensland, Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and New South Wales growth markets, including Sydney’s growth areas, the Hunter and the Central Coast, then narrow the field suburb by suburb.

Is enough new housing supply coming?

No — the supply pipeline is still under pressure, which supports the case for quality new housing in the right locations. The National Housing Supply and Affordability Council’s August 2026 report estimated the 1.2 million-home Housing Accord target would be reached in the December quarter of 2030, one quarter later than previously expected, with NSW tracking to March 2032 and Queensland to March 2031.

Approvals are not giving the market much comfort either. The ABS reported total dwelling approvals fell 6.1% in August 2026 to 16,953 dwellings, with private dwellings excluding houses down 21.2%, townhouses down 20.7%, and Queensland apartment approvals falling to 337 from 1,330 in July.

For investors, that is a big deal. If prices are resetting now while future housing delivery is delayed, the window is open to secure quality stock before confidence returns. That does not mean buy blindly. It means get your strategy ready while most people are still reading yesterday’s scary headline.

New builds also deserve attention because the tax landscape has changed. ATO guidance on the 2026-27 reforms states that from 1 July 2027 negative gearing for residential property is limited to new builds, while established properties bought after 7:30pm AEST on 12 May 2026 face tighter offset rules. New-build investors can also choose between the 50% CGT discount and indexation under the reforms. Speak to your accountant about your own position, but understand the direction: quality new housing is being pushed to the front of the investor conversation.

Why can fewer investors make the opportunity better?

Fewer investors can mean less competition for good assets. The ABS reported that in the June quarter 2026, the number of new investor dwelling loan commitments fell 8.6% and the value fell 10.2%.

That is exactly when prepared investors can get paid for being organised. While others pause, you can clean up your borrowing position, define your suburb criteria, and secure access to sites before they are pushed to the public market.

This is where Inner Circle Group’s off-market-first model matters. We give members access to off-market property in Australia, typically 4-6 weeks before public release, so you are not fighting the whole market for leftovers. In a downturn, the best deal is not always the biggest discount. It is often the best site, in the right estate, before the crowd wakes up.

“Gut instinct is for rookies. In a downturn, emotion gets louder, so your process has to get sharper,” says Ben Ferrett. “If the data does not stack up, we do not touch it.”

What should you avoid buying in a downturn?

You should avoid anything that only looks good because the price has fallen. A discount is not a strategy. A cheap mistake is still a mistake.

  • Weak rental depth: if there are not enough tenants at the right rent, the headline yield can fall apart quickly.
  • Oversupplied pockets: avoid areas where too much similar stock is competing for the same tenant and resale buyer.
  • Compromised product: poor floorplans, awkward sites, bad orientation and weak street appeal do not magically become good because the market is down.
  • One-industry towns: employment diversity matters when confidence is fragile.
  • Speculative assets: if the deal only works if rates fall or prices rebound quickly, it is not robust enough.

That is why product mix is critical. The same suburb might support a townhouse better than an apartment, or a house and land package better than both. You do not buy the suburb alone. You buy the right product inside the right suburb at the right price.

What should investors target instead?

Investors should target quality new-build assets in undersupplied growth corridors where jobs, infrastructure, population growth and rental depth are all pointing in the same direction. That is the difference between buying the dip and building a portfolio.

For ICG, the opportunity set is national. Brisbane and South East Queensland offer scale and infrastructure-led growth. Perth has affordability and population momentum. Adelaide is a core market with tight rental conditions and strong relative value; if you are assessing an investment property Adelaide opportunity, the rental data now demands respect. Melbourne and New South Wales growth markets can also work when the suburb and product selection are ruthless.

New build is central to the strategy because it gives investors modern tenant appeal, lower maintenance risk early in the ownership cycle, depreciation potential to discuss with an accountant, and alignment with the new tax settings. If you are comparing established versus a new build investment property, do not compare price alone. Compare cash flow, tenant demand, tax treatment, land component, supply risk and resale depth.

We have seen how powerful the right process can be. Rhenda, a Victorian investor, was nervous about buying outside Victoria when she bought in Deception Bay, Queensland, through Ben in 2024. Her tenant was secured before the property was rent-ready, and her recent valuation came in over $200,000 above purchase price. That is not a promise for anyone else; it is proof that buying interstate can work when the research and execution are right.

How does Inner Circle Group assess downturn opportunities?

Inner Circle Group assesses downturn opportunities by scoring the suburb before it scores the discount. Our how to choose a suburb to invest in (the ICG Suburb Scoring Engine) process exists because buying on fear, hope or a pretty display home is not good enough.

Every suburb is rated across five weighted pillars: future growth catalysts, supply and demand, liveability and connectivity, economics, and demographics. We then layer in product-mix analysis, compare the suburb with the five nearest alternatives, and present the opportunity across 18 data points backed by in-house economic analysis.

In a downturn, those pillars become even more important. Future growth catalysts tell us whether infrastructure, transport and employment hubs are likely to deepen demand. Supply and demand tells us whether today’s discount is genuine opportunity or a warning sign. Liveability and connectivity tell us whether tenants will actually want to live there. Economics tells us whether local incomes and jobs support rents. Demographics tell us who the future buyer and tenant are likely to be.

Then we physically walk the site. Desktop research is powerful, but it does not show you the feel of the street, the slope of the block, the surrounding stock, the noise, or whether the best lots have already been taken. This is the heavy lifting most investors simply do not have the time, access or experience to do properly.

When should you act?

You should act when the numbers stack up before confidence returns. Waiting for everyone to feel safe usually means waiting until the leverage has gone.

That does not mean rushing. It means getting finance clarity, setting your buying rules, and using the downturn to negotiate on assets that would have been harder to secure in a hotter market. Inner Circle Group helps members with strategy, finance connections, acquisition, build support, tenant coordination and post-settlement guidance through dedicated Member Experience Managers.

Key takeaways

  • A downturn is not automatically bad for investors; it can improve entry conditions.
  • Late-2026 price falls are happening alongside record rents and tight vacancy in key markets.
  • Population growth and delayed housing supply still support the long-term need for well-located homes.
  • The opportunity is not cheap property; it is quality property with stronger buyer leverage.
  • Use data, suburb scoring and product analysis before you buy.

If you want to use this downturn properly, do not sit on the sidelines waiting for perfect confidence. Book your free strategy session with the Inner Circle team or call 1300 037 344, and we will show you where the numbers are pointing before the crowd catches up.

Frequently asked questions

Should I buy an investment property when prices are falling?

You can, but only if the fundamentals support the purchase. Falling prices improve buyer leverage, but the asset still needs strong rental demand, limited supply risk, quality product design, good connectivity and a clear long-term demand story.

Is a downturn better for first-time property investors?

It can be, because there may be less competition and more room to negotiate. The danger is buying purely because something looks cheaper. First-time investors should get finance clarity, define their strategy and use suburb-level data before making an offer.

Which Australian markets should investors watch in a downturn?

ICG is focused on undersupplied growth corridors across Brisbane and South East Queensland, Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and New South Wales, including Sydney growth areas, the Hunter and Central Coast. The right suburb and product matter more than the city headline.

Are new builds better than established properties after the tax changes?

New builds have become more important under the 2026-27 tax reforms, especially around negative gearing from 1 July 2027. However, tax outcomes depend on your personal situation, so speak to your accountant and broker before making decisions.

How do I reduce risk when buying in a downturn?

Avoid emotional buying. Focus on vacancy, rental depth, population growth, supply pipeline, employment diversity, infrastructure and product fit. Inner Circle Group uses its Suburb Scoring Engine and site inspections to filter opportunities before members see them.

Does Inner Circle Group only recommend one market?

No. ICG builds nationally diversified portfolios rather than chasing one hot tip. The team assesses multiple major capital-city growth corridors and selects opportunities based on data, access, product quality and each member’s strategy.

Sources

About the author – Ben Ferrett, Founder & CEO, Inner Circle Group
Ben Ferrett founded Inner Circle Group after more than a decade of hands-on experience in the Australian residential property market, starting with his own portfolio and then helping friends and family do the same. He has been featured in the Australian Financial Review and on Channel 7 News for his work in off-market property. Connect with Ben on LinkedIn.

Book your free strategy session with the Inner Circle team → or call 1300 037 344.

General information only. This article does not take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. Consider seeking advice from a licensed professional before making investment decisions.

Inner Circle

Inner Circle Group was founded by Ben Ferrett, a residential property expert with more than a decade of hands-on experience in the Australian property market.

Ben began by building his own residential property position, learning how access, relationships, and preparation shaped better outcomes than timing or luck. As results became clear, close friends and family asked for guidance. Ben shared his approach, his relationships, and his access to off-market opportunities. Their success became the foundation of what would later become Inner Circle Group, named after the very people it began with.